RITUAL IN THE NEW CHURCH GEORGE DE CHARMS 1933
NEW CHURCH LIFE
VOL. LIII JANUARY, 1933 No. 1
(Delivered at the Pittsburgh and Ontario District Assemblies, 1932.)
Worship is not a gesture, but an affection of the heart. It is a thing, not of the body, but of the spirit; for "God is a Spirit, and they that worship Him must worship Him in spirit and in truth." (John 4:24.) To worship the Lord in spirit is to love Him as the Only Creator, the Only Provider, the Only Protector; it is to acknowledge that we have no life, no ability to do good, no power to resist evil, except from Him, and thus that we stand in perpetual dependence upon Him. It is a state of prayer, of inmost humility before the Lord, in which there is not only the realization that we are completely dependent upon Him, but at the same time a feeling of trust, of confidence, a sense of peace and contentment, a joy of heart, that it should be so. Where this spirit of worship exists, there is a living religion, a living church. Where it is lacking, whatever may be the pomp of external form and ritual, the church is dead, and the way of eternal life is closed.
The Writings emphasize this spiritual essence of religion. They decry mere formalism, not only as useless, and powerless to save, but as positively injurious, because hypocritical; insincere, and therefore repellent to the angels. They teach, indeed, that worship cannot exist as a disembodied spirit. The affections of the heart must find expression in the speech and act of the body, if it is to live and grow. Yet its primary manifestation is not in ritualistic forms, but in the life of charity,-in active use to the neighbor through one's daily function or calling.
Truly to love the Lord is to desire above all things to do His will. It is the Lord's will to save all men, to feed them, and to lift them up forever. Uses are but means to this end, and they have been given in part into the hands of men, that in them man may actually co-operate with the Divine will, and in so doing may manifest, confirm, and establish his love to the Lord.
Every service which one may perform for society, even though in outward seeming it may be confined to the needs of the body and the world, conceals within it a use to the spirit. It may be a vehicle for the transfer of spiritual blessings, for ministry to spiritual ends. In Providence, indeed, it becomes such a vehicle, in ways far beyond our human knowledge or comprehension, if it is done from love to the Lord and charity. Such a life of charity is that in which the spirit of worship finds its normal expression and fulfilment; and here it dwells as in its own living body.
It is only through this body of use to the neighbor that the spirit of worship can actually effect man's regeneration and salvation. For we are born into the love of self, the desire for self-aggrandizement, self-advantage, self-power, and exaltation over others. This love is the very opposite of love to the Lord, which seeks the happiness of others in self-forgetting service. These two opposite loves cannot exist together in the same human mind. They are mutually destructive. One must become dominant, and must subject the other to its will.
Yet the love of self is innate with us, and until it is overcome by actual conflict we may indeed intellectually conceive of love to the Lord as desirable, but it cannot be our real love. It is but an imaginary thing with us. It becomes real only through actual warfare against the love of self. And the ground, the field, of this spiritual battle is the plane of use, of everyday work, of active service to the neighbor. This may be performed for the sake of self,-for the sake of wealth and reputation and fame, in which alone we place success; or it may be performed for the sake of the Lord, for the sake of His kingdom, for the furtherance of His Divine end of salvation, from charity and good-will toward others, without thought of personal reward. This latter cannot be done, however, without temptation, in which the former is resisted and overcome, insomuch that the love of self is rejected, and love to the Lord becomes our real love.
3
This victory in temptation is the process of regeneration, through which the spirit of worship purifies the life, the mind, and the heart of man, and makes him new. Such a regeneration does not and can not take place in the observance of external rituals or the formularies of worship, but is effected solely by means of a life of use from charity. For which reason we are taught that "religion is of life, and the life of religion is to do good."
II.
Because of this teaching, oft-repeated in the Writings, it has been supposed by many in the New Church that rituals are of little or no importance. There has been a tendency to look upon them with something of fear and distrust. Some have gone so far as to hold that in a truly spiritual and internal church they should be dispensed with entirely. Others, although recognizing that they are necessary, have felt that they must be kept as simple and unpretentious as possible, lest they should interfere with that religion of life which is the only ground of regeneration. It has been felt that the real purpose of external worship is not ritualistic observance, but intellectual instruction, through which we may attain to a deeper and truer understanding of the Word as the law of life, as the way by which we may perform uses from charity, and thus from the Lord.
This conclusion has been the more readily adopted because of the temperament of our people. The New Church has been established for the most part among the Nordic races, which are not emotional by temperament. Our background is one of restraint. We learn from early childhood to conceal our inner feelings, for which reason we are apt to experience a self-consciousness in the open expression of them. To this is to be added the fact that the New Church has grown up in the midst of a bitter conflict among the Christian sects, between ritualists and non-ritualists, between those who hold that an elaborate mode of external worship is essential to salvation, and those who have revolted against it as idolatrous, hypocritical, and destructive of spiritual life.
4
The personnel of the New Church has been drawn largely from the ranks of the dissenters, who inherit a deeply implanted distaste for ritual.
Further, the first task of the Church in its beginning lay in the establishment of its doctrine, and in a conflict against the opposing beliefs and dogmas of modern Christianity. To this the main energies of the Church have of necessity been devoted, leaving relatively little time or opportunity for a concentration upon the development of external worship. This need is still paramount, and will remain so for a long time to come. Yet the time has come when we must recognize the teachings of the Writings concerning worship itself as one of those essential and distinctive doctrines by which the Church is to be established in the world. A clear understanding of that doctrine is the first step in the development of a true New Church ritual, which will take its rightful place in relation to love to the Lord and charity towards the neighbor.
And finally, because ritual, in order that it may express the real inner life of the church, must be a gradual growth; and because it cannot be invented, lest it become a purely artificial thing, but must advance naturally as an outward expression of the slowly developing internal spirit of the church; therefore, in order that we may have any ritual at all, we have been compelled to borrow freely from the past, accepting the forms which have grown up in the Christian churches out of which we have come, making therein only such changes and adaptations as were necessary to eliminate obvious falsities of doctrine.
All of these reasons have combined to cause the development of rituals in the New Church to be slow. Yet if we study the Writings, and reflect upon their teachings, we will see that, while the external forms of worship are there assigned a position entirely subordinate to a life of use, they are none the less important and necessary to the establishment of the Church. For while love to the Lord is the soul or spirit, and a life of charity toward the neighbor from that love is the living body, these externals of worship are the garments of religion.
In its complex, such worship is called the life of piety, of which it is said that "Divine worship consists primarily in performing uses, but secondarily in the life of piety. (H. D. 124.) And again, "With the man of the church, there must be the life of charity and there must be the life of piety; they must be joined together.
5
The life of piety without the life of charity is profitable for nothing; but the former together with the latter is profitable for all things." (A. C. 8252.)
This teaching is easily understood if we regard piety as a garment and charity as the body. For garments are entirely secondary to the body in importance. Apart from it they are dead, and profitable for nothing. Yet they are necessary for the protection of the body, for the preservation of its health, and are useful for its adornment. Indeed, the body cannot live without their protection. And when they are conjoined with the body, when they are worn with a view to protecting and increasing the use of the body, then do they, as it were, receive life from the body. They contribute to the same use, in that they reveal the mind and spirit, express the inner thought and affection, imparting to them tangible form and substance, in which and through which the man may be seen and known. Their vital importance becomes further evident if we consider that the four essentials of which they consist are prayer, praise, instruction from the Word, and partaking of the Sacraments. All of these are directly commanded by the Lord.
He taught His Disciples to pray. When, at the triumphal entry into Jerusalem, His followers sang, "Blessed is He that cometh in the name of the Lord; peace in heaven, and glory in the highest," the Pharisees wished Him to rebuke them. But "He answered, and said unto them, I tell you that if these should hold their peace, the stones would immediately cry out." (Luke 20:38-40.) To the scribes and Pharisees He said, "Search the Scriptures, for in them ye think ye have eternal life, and they are they which testify of me." (John 5:39.) And concerning the Holy Supper He commanded His Disciples, "This do in remembrance of me." In these, and many other places, the Sacred Scripture enjoins external worship upon the Church.
How important this is, the Writings bear further testimony, giving rational reasons why it should be so. Thus we are told in A. C. 1083 that "man, for the most part, is such that he does not know what the internal man is, and what belongs to the internal man; and therefore, unless there were external worship, he would know nothing whatever of what is holy."
6
It is further taught that rituals excite internal things, and rouse the affections, especially those of love to the Lord and charity. They bring influx from heaven, and the presence of angelic societies. They tend to withdraw the mind from the cares of the body and the world, and dispose it to the reception of heavenly truth. Thus, by means of them, remains of heavenly states are stored up, which give new spiritual strength, and power of resistance in time of temptation.
So deeply do these states affect man, and so intimately are they associated in the mind with the external acts which were the occasion of entrance into them, that these ritualistic observances are implanted in man's spirit, and are retained by him in the other world. In them and through them the Lord touches his heart, to teach and to lead. They become the embodiment of holiness, and the dwelling place of the Lord with Him. For this reason they are most precious, and cannot be destroyed or taken away without serious injury to the spiritual life. They become, therefore, a powerful means of Divine operation, looking to man's regeneration and salvation. Without this means, no church can come into existence. For without it man could receive no conscious perception of the Lord's presence; he could be affected by no conscious influence of heavenly spheres; his mind would not be prepared for the reception of Divine Truth. Thus he could not know the Lord; and without knowledge, love cannot be implanted. Wherefore, without it the very soul of religion, namely, love to the Lord, could not be given.
The very beginning of spiritual life with man is in remains, and particularly in the remains of worship imbued from earliest infancy. Nor can the temporary vision of the Lord, the momentary experience of love to Him, which arises out of these remains, possibly be preserved, strengthened, and perfected, without a continual return to those externals of worship into which the Lord and heaven may inflow anew. Without this we quickly fall back into our natural affections, become wholly engrossed in the affairs of the world and the pursuit of our personal desires and ambitions, and lose that vision of the Lord and of heaven which alone can inspire us to fight against the innate evils of our heredity.
This is the reason why, from most ancient times, the Sabbath Day has been set apart for the worship of the Lord, and why that worship consists in external representative acts, intended to separate the mind from its usual burden of bodily cares, and to lift it up into the sphere and the light of heaven.
7
It is because we need this frequent renewal of our spiritual loves, in order that we may persist in the endeavor to reform our life, and establish charity or love to the neighbor actually in our work and service to our fellow men, that external worship is vitally important. When ritual has this end in view, then does it perform an essential use to the living body of the church, for its protection, and for the preservation of its health.
III.
But, granted the use of ritual, what should be the nature of external worship in the New Church? Should it be rich, elaborate, highly complicated! Or should it remain simple, unassuming, unpretentious?
It is our belief that all ritual should be simple. For simplicity is essential to sincerity. There is no worship in external pomp and show. These are expressive of self-love, of pride, rather than of that state of humility before the Lord which is the very essence of worship.
But let us understand well what we mean by simplicity. It does not imply barrenness, or absence of beauty. Simplicity is indeed the soul of art, the soul of beauty. Yet its beauty is various according to circumstances. It lies in that which is appropriate, in that which is a complete expression of the inner spirit, the inner state at the time. It requires the elimination of all that is superfluous, meaningless, insincere and unconvincing. These things are the result of imitation, of mere invention, lacking the inspiration of the soul. They are accumulations which gather about art in its decline. They are signs of decay and death. But true simplicity, living beauty, cannot be attained by merely removing these excrescences. It is not attained by the mere negation of art. It does not result from replacing insincere ornamentation by barrenness, by ugliness, by a contempt for beauty and a disregard for all its laws.
Art is creative. It is the spontaneous expression of an inner soul or spirit. It is true art in the degree that it faithfully displays that spirit. The Lord is the origin of all beauty. The spirit of love to Him, the effort to represent Him, the endeavor to rouse the mind to a realization of His presence, must clothe itself in forms of beauty.
8
It cannot otherwise be simple. It cannot otherwise express its true quality, with faithfulness and sincerity. Ritual, therefore, may be rich in beauty, and at the same time be utterly simple. For ritual is an art; indeed, it is the highest of all the arts; and where there is no beauty there is no art.
It is inevitable that the ritual which grows up in the New Church, expressive of the spirit of worship there, because it is the garment of the Church as the "bride adorned for her Husband," should possess a beauty which arises from the highest combination of all the arts. It should strive for beauty of sound, for poetry, for richness of color and design, for perfection of rhythm and movement. For all these things are representative of heaven, and of the Lord who is in heaven. And yet, above all, it should strive for simplicity, for an utter sincerity, holding in abhorrence mere pomp, external show, meaningless ornamentation.
There are several means by which this simplicity may be attained. First, our ritual must be distinctive. It must arise out of the spirit of the New Church, and must express that spirit. We must not rest satisfied with the mere imitation of forms, however perfect, which have been developed by an alien spirit. We cannot be content to take over the rituals of a former Church. Secondly, it cannot be invented. It must not be the ingenious creation of a single mind imbued with some intellectual idea. If it is to express the spirit of the Church, it must grow with the Church. It must arise out of a common feeling, a common consciousness, as a thing natural and spontaneous. For this reason it cannot be imposed upon the Church by ecclesiastical authority. It must come in answer to a call, a felt need of the Church. This call must come, not from without, but from within. It must come from the truth of the Word, the truth of the Writings seen and understood, from a desire to express that truth by appropriate representation.
Again, the ritual of the New Church must be free to develop variously with different peoples, according to their temperament, their background of religious feeling, their native character. It will indeed possess an internal unity, derived from the common source, out of which all the ritual of the Church will be drawn, namely, from the Heavenly Doctrine. But it will not be a unity of sameness, but of great variety, representative of the unity in God, in Whom all things are distinctly One.
9
Further our ritual must be appropriate to the time and the occasion. The service of a cathedral may be equally as simple as the service in a home, but their simplicity will not be identical. The one would not be appropriate, and therefore would not be simple, in the other. Appropriateness arises from complete adaptation to the place, the need, the situation, the use. And herein lies true simplicity, and genuine beauty.
But, above all, the ritual of the New Church must be an appropriate ultimate into which our love to the Lord may flow, and out of which it may arise in us anew, refreshed and revivified. It must be such as to bring the Lord and heaven present in objective form before our minds. And to do this, even in the midst of the most primitive conditions, there must be in it the essential elements of beauty.
If such a ritual, distinctly expressive of the New Church, is to arise with us, we must seek for the principles of its development in the Writings. Many have felt that, because rituals are in themselves unessential, because they are the mere garments of religion, they should be regarded purely as matters of personal taste. Since they are an art, they are indeed matters of taste, but not of mere personal preference. Our natural preferences are by no means infallible. They arise from early associations, from emotional states, which have little or nothing to do with the intrinsic value of that which is preferred. We like or dislike certain names, largely because of persons or characters with which they have become associated in our minds. Our taste in music, in architecture, in literature, in painting, depends largely upon our training and environment.
Quite apart from our individual feeling or opinion, there is both good and bad taste in all art. We are under the necessity of acquiring an appreciation of that which is really good, and this from an intellectual acknowledgment of its superiority. We must train our senses to perceive and to distinguish the higher values. It is not otherwise with the art of ritual. Our undisciplined preferences are unreliable. If we see clearly from the Writings that this art is of the highest value in the establishment of the Church, we will seek consciously to cultivate our taste for that which is truly good, truly beautiful, and truly appropriate in ritual.
10
Here, as in every other art, we will educate our children to appreciate what is best and finest. We will put aside our prejudices, our unthinking, emotional preferences, in an endeavor to lift our tastes to a higher standard.
If, for instance, we consider the hymns we happen to like, reflecting upon the reasons for our choice, and how fully that choice depends upon individual association and early training, we will find an illustration of how undependable these preferences are. They have nothing to do with the intrinsic value of the music, the actual power and poetry of the words, the depth of the sentiment expressed. They arise solely from the fact that these have become associated in our minds with states of spiritual exaltation, with delights of worship, with remains of childhood memories. And for this reason no two people will agree in their choice.
If ritual is to grow into a thing of beauty, we must not rest satisfied with these preferences, setting them up as a just standard of judgment for ourselves and others. We must not seek to perpetuate them with our children. We must consider what is inherently good, inherently beautiful, and seek to cultivate the love of this with ourselves and with our children. We must reason in this matter, not from tradition, nor from the standards of the world, nor from prejudices deep-rooted in our minds by heredity and environmental training, but from the Writings, from the inner vision of heavenly truth and heavenly beauty which they impart. This it is that we must learn to love; for the love of this is one with the love of the Writings, and with the love of the Lord seen in the Writings. Ritual that is born of such an endeavor will express the spirit of the Church,-the spirit of humility, of willingness to be taught by the Lord, and the recognition that all our appreciation of true beauty must be derived from Him.
This, indeed, has been the mode of progress in the Church from its beginning, not only in ritual, but also in doctrine, in life, in every truly distinctive thing that has been developed with us. It has arisen from a loyal devotion to the Writings, and from a resistance to our personal feelings, our established customs and habits, for the sake of bringing our thought and life into more perfect accord with the Writings.
11
If we read the history of the past, it will become evident that all those distinctive things which are now deeply associated with the New Church in our minds,-an ordained priesthood, episcopal government, priestly vestments, the opening of the Word in worship, as well as the principles of the Academy, New Church education, distinctive social life,-all were adopted only after a bitter struggle against individual ideas and preferences. It was because men were willing to follow the Lord, willing to follow the clear teaching of His Word, and to forsake all things of self, in an endeavor to open the way for the fullest possible establishment of His Kingdom in the world, that the Church has grown spiritually, from generation to generation.
This complete loyalty to the Heavenly Doctrine is indeed the very essence of that which we call the "Academy Spirit." In the degree that this spirit prevails, distinctive rituals, as fitting and beautiful garments for our internal worship of the Lord, must of necessity arise with us. And in their beauty and their spiritual simplicity they will exert an ever-increasing power to implant early remains of affection for the New Church with our children, the power to impart a renewal of inspiration and of spiritual vision to all who enter into them, a power to bring the Lord present in His Glorified Human, that in the beauty of holiness the Divine may be with men.
No other result can follow, if we remain true to the Heavenly Doctrine, in spirit and in life. For then will the Church become in truth the "King's Daughter," of whom it is said in David: "Hearken, O daughter, and incline thine ear; forget also thine own people and thy father's house; so shall the King greatly desire thy beauty; for He is thy Lord, and worship thou Him. . . . The King's daughter is all glorious within; her garment is of the inweavings of gold. In raiment of needlework shall she be brought unto the King." (Psalm 45:10, 11, 13, 14.)
12