FEAR FOR THE FOUNDATIONS Rev. WILLIAM WHITEHEAD 1938
NEW CHURCH LIFE
VOL. LVIII JANUARY, 1938 No. 1
"In the Lord put I my trust: how say ye to my soul, Flee as a bird to your mountain For, lo, the wicked bend their bow, they make ready their arrow upon the string, that they may privily, shoot at the upright in heart. If the foundations be destroyed, what can the righteous do The Lord is in His holy temple, the Lord's throne is in heaven." (Psalm 11:1-4.)
David sits in the midst of an atmosphere of gloom and fear. The whisperings of treachery are round about his throne. Absalom works in secret against his own father. Even at the gates of the palace he sows sedition. He arouses murmurings and discontents against the king's justice. He privately steals the hearts of the leaders of the army and of the people. Before long these whispers are to rise into a storm of revolution that will shake the very pillars of the state and menace the life of the king.
So the friends of David come in fear and trembling to counsel him to flee to the mountains. All is lost. The forces of rebellion are already too strong to resist. Assassins are waiting to bend the bow against the leading men of the kingdom. The darkness of impending judgment is on them. The advice of despair is in their mouths. What can the righteous do?
Yet, in this dark and hopeless hour of panic, there comes the answer, born of the faith and courage of a king, "In the Lord put I my trust." And in an outburst of kingly wrath, he turns on the timid group of counselors: "How say ye to my soul, Flee as a bird to your mountain! For, lo, the wicked bend their bow, they make ready their arrow upon the string, that they may privily shoot at the upright in heart. If the foundations be destroyed, what can the righteous do! The Lord is in His holy temple, the Lord's throne is in heaven."
These words of the Hebrew king and his counsellors are not only part of the great ecclesiastical drama of decline and vastation in the Israelitish Church; they are also prophetic of those states in which the world finds itself at this day. In both Church and State-those two great institutions which embody the uses of the soul and body of mankind-there is no problem that presses more insistently than this state of distrust of the power of Divine Truth,-a state represented by the so-called friends of David.
In the Christian world there is a pervading sense of insecurity, of fear and agitation, of riotous and irrational optimism, alternating with states of deep despair, lest the foundations of faith and life should be proved to be not only defective and worthless, but perhaps even totally destroyed. In religion, philosophy, science, government, and in all the uses of man, there exists a perception that the fundamentals of human life are in danger, that in some way men have left the sure path that might have led to happiness and peace, and are treading on the shifting sands of error and illusion.
In these straits men are asking themselves-as did the courtiers of the Hebrew king-what they are to do? And the same counsel that was given by the friends of David is also given to them,-flight.
"Flee as a bird to the mountain!"
In the good sense, "mountain" signifies the good of love and of charity. But in the opposite sense, as here, it signifies the love of self and the love of the world, and the evils thence derived. Herein is involved the temptation to yield spiritual good to the good of the natural man,-to flee from the conflict of reformation and regeneration which genuine acceptance of the Divine Truth brings.
The false advice tendered is: Let your reason be satisfied with love alone. Do not attempt to wrestle with false doctrines and anti-spiritual theories. Do not enter into conflict or warfare for the sake of faith. Do not provoke controversy for the sake of mere understanding. It is impossible for the understanding of the man of the church to resist those whose subtle reasonings and ideas come with such scientific accuracy and trained precision.
3
The arrow comes in the darkness, comes clothed in appearances, appearances taken from the natural world, appearances arising from fallacies born in the nimble and ingenious minds of learned men, appearances taken from the letter of the Word itself. It is useless to resist under these conditions, they plead. It is not faith alone, but good alone, they say, that makes the church, that will save man and all his works. The only thing to do is to take refuge in a good life, and let spiritual doctrines go.
Hence it has come about that men counsel flight from the greatest problem of human life, namely, the relation of God's revelation to man's reason. They seek refuge in an ignoble surrender to the enemies and deniers of a spiritual world, of a Divine code of life and faith, of a personal immortality, and of the Redeemer and Savior of mankind. But to these spiritual pacifists of olden time and present time there is given the steadfast answer of the Hebrew king, who remains on his throne, saying, "In the Lord put I my trust."
In another aspect, the temptation is towards frank paganism. The recommendation of the natural man is, to flee swiftly to the consolations of self and the world. Take refuge from the anxiety and stress of spiritual conflict by flying to the pagan's delight in the world of the senses. Put aside the problems of spiritual truth and good. Find happiness in the nature of the natural world,-in the nature that is your own, in the society of those whose nature is like unto yours. Let the delights of the world and self be the arbiter of your life. Let the sense of doctrinal responsibility and duty go. Leave the problems of theology to those who are able and willing to find an answer. Or submerge thought itself in an orgy of pleasure.
"Flee to the mountains of self-love and pride," whisper the voices of these counsellors. "Why continue steadfast to the platitudes of an old order,-to the well-worn antiquated steps that lead painfully to an undermined throne? Let religion abdicate its untenable position, and admit that the devices and subtleties of man's reason have prevailed. Let religion abandon its doctrinal pretensions as a leader of thought, and administer to the natural loves of men in comfortable moral service."
The answer of the Psalmist, who spoke better than he knew, and better than he was, is to be the answer of the man of the church: "In the Lord put I my trust."
4
What is the significance of this Psalm but that the Lord Himself will fight for the good against the evil, and. that if a man love Him, and love the neighbor, the Divine justice and judgment will operate to the confusion of the wicked, with all the certainty and inevitableness of a law of the physical universe.
Yet, unless the mind can penetrate more deeply into the mysteries of the letter, there is here but an appearance of blind confidence,-an appearance of the unreasoning faith of a king who is loyal to his God. Confidence, in itself, however sincere, is no proof of the validity of faith. Many rulers in society and the church have exhibited the utmost confidence in those ruling ideas and affections which have governed them, and by which their followers have consented to be governed. But time has revealed the falsity or evil of their state; even as many of the creeds made by men and councils of men-the "wisest" of their time-have furnished no safe foundations for the church or for the faith of man. Indeed, it is this fact of the inadequacy of simple obedience at this day that is aiding powerfully in the overthrow of the authority of modern religion over men's lives. The upright in heart cannot stand in their affection without Divine Truth.
There must be more than the loyal affection for what is considered to be the highest good, if there is to be genuine and abiding religion. There must be the love of that which is seen specifically to be the truth. And if that truth is to be the foundation of man's eternal life, then it must be eternal and Divine truth, able to stand forever against all the assaults that the minds of men can devise, and against all the treacheries that evil spirits can contrive. Obedience without understanding is not the quality of genuine faith for the man of the New Church.
It is true that in the spiritual world a new natural heaven could be formed from those (even of the Israelitish Church) who had been In a state of mere simple obedience,-such obedience as is represented in the text. It is true that, in the early Christian Church, many of the simple partook of such a state, just as children and the simple may still partake of it in the early states of the New Church. But this is not a state in which a man may stay at this day and still progress in spiritual stature, or in which he may even stand still with safety.
5
Indeed, those foundations of a man's life which are laid in childhood,-those remains which are the footstool of the Lord and His angels,-would seem at this day to be in peculiar danger of destruction. And this despite the ceaseless care and vigilance of Him who slumbers not nor sleeps, that man may rise to eternal life. That this is true, may be seen in the light of natural reason alone, on the plane of exterior conscience. For while it is true that the sciences and knowledges of corporeal and sensual truth have been providentially multiplied for the use of the gentile state as never before, yet it is also true that the universal truths of the letter of the Word,-the truth of the Divinity of God's written revelation to men, the truth of the Divine Human of the Lord, the truth that there is a life after death, involving a heaven and a hell,-truths that are fundamental to the reception of all spiritual life;-these truths are being perverted and poisoned by the subtle insinuation of self-loves and world-loves, to such a degree that the innocent and sincere affections of the simple for them are constantly in process of destruction.
This may be illustrated especially by the state of the present Gentile world. As never before in man's history, what remains of genuine charity with the Gentile races is being turned to hatred and scorn. East and West were never so far apart, though in the sharing of natural truths and goods they were never So near. The integrity and simplicity of the Gentile races have suffered from their increasing contacts with the evils and falses of a Christian civilization whose spiritual foundations have given way,-a civilization Christian in name only, whose example and precept have made wholesale theft and murder the instruments of policy of modern nationalism.
The seeds of good and truth with the simple Christian are being torn from the ground wherein they might have grown, and scattered on stony ground to please the whim of modern self-intelligence. In general, on the plane of the exterior conscience,-the conscience of moral and civil good and truth,-on this plane that underlies all the works of man, and without which neither the home, the school, nor the Church can endure,-the states of the simple and the children are continually assailed.
What, then, is the ultimate answer to the plea, "What shall the righteous do?"-in the face of the helpless condition of the Gentile state? The answer may be found in that which is the foundation of civilization,-the Divine Truth of the Decalogue.
6
The essential laws of all orderly civil and moral life are: to respect and render loyalty to the uses of parents, masters and rulers;-not to kill the neighbor;-not to commit adultery;-not to steal the neighbor's possessions;-not to bear false witness against the neighbor;-not to be covetous of anything that is the neighbor's. These seven rules are the essence of all law and order and freedom in this natural world. They are the primary laws of natural justice, of political life and liberty, and of the economics of all forms of use. Without the acknowledgment of these rules, and obedience to them, there can be no orderly form of human civilization, whether the form of the government be that of an empire, a kingdom, a republic, a city, or a home.
For these laws apply with even greater force to nations than to men;-that nations shall not overthrow the human society of world wide law and order,-that they shall not wantonly kill the people of a neighbor kingdom;-that they shall not destroy the Divinely appointed institution of the family;-that they shall not invade the neighbor's possessions;-nor bear false witness against another people;-nor covet what rightly belongs to them. Who cannot see that the breaking of these seven laws of man's natural life is the cause of every upheaval and revolution in the foundations of society?
If these seven laws be broken, it matters not how great the quantity of natural knowledges and culture,-the sciences, the arts, the philosophies;-these are soon swept along into mere wreckage by the tides of men's evil passions. For civilization cannot be saved alone by the building of bigger and more efficient social institutions. The means of man's salvation are spiritual, not sociological. The enemies of the social order are the evils and falsities that assail the hearts of the upright. "For, lo, the wicked bend their bow, they make ready the arrow upon the string, that they may privily shoot at the upright in heart."
The seven commandments of civil and moral order are the supreme conscience of mankind. And those with whom there is something of a natural-rational mind as yet unperverted, who are still able to see what is naturally just and fair in their relations with other men, who can receive these commandments and follow them with affection for the sake of justice, compelling themselves to obey them;-such men are the conscience of human society, and the natural guardians of the state, as of Divine right.
7
For genuine conscience is of God even as the life of a seed is from God. It is organized conscience and not organized knowledge, that is the fulcrum of a growing civilization. The Golden Age died through knowledge. The Silver Age was saved through conscience. And any system of social education which seeks to advance mankind through faith alone in knowledge destroys truly human society at its very roots.
These seven laws that are proper to the truly human conscience-the conscience that distinguishes man from all the rest of natural creation,-also make the body of the church on earth. Without them there could be no church. By means of them man can conjoin himself with the Lord. And if, at the same time, he will obey the three Divine laws of spiritual life set forth in the first three Commandments,-acknowledging and obeying the Lord as the Head of His Church and the Fountain of all its government,-the Lord will then conjoin Himself with man. Thus man's civilization-his culture, both individual and collective-may become both spiritual and natural, and his citizenship as of heaven. This process is thus described in the Heavenly Doctrine:
"Man has the affection of knowing from his earliest childhood, and by it he learns many things which will be of use to him, and many things which will be of no use. When he grows up, by application to some business, he imbibes and learns the details that relate to his business; this then becomes his use, with which he is affected. Thus the affection of use makes the beginning, and this produces an affection for the means, by which he masters his business, which is his use. . . . Since, however, this use, together with the means of attaining it, is for the sake of life in this world, the affection of it is natural.
"But because every man not only regards the uses conducive to life in this world, but also ought to regard the uses conducive to a life in heaven (for he is to enter into that life after his life in the world, and to live therein to eternity), therefore everyone from his childhood procures for himself cognitions of truth and good from the Word, or from the doctrine of the church, or from preaching, which will be conducive to that life; and he stores them up in his natural memory, acquiring them in greater or less abundance according to his connate affection of knowing, and according as this is increased by various exciting causes.
"But all these cognitions, whatever may be their number and quality, are only a store, out of which the faith of charity may be formed: and this faith is not formed, except in proportion as he shuns evils as sins. If he shuns evils as sins, then these cognitions become cognitions of a faith in which there is spiritual life; but if he does not shun evils as sins, these cognitions are merely cognitions, and do not become the cognitions of a faith which has any spiritual life in it.
8
"This store is absolutely necessary, since faith cannot be formed without it. For cognitions of truth and good enter into faith, and make it. If they are wanting, faith does not come into existence; for a faith entirely empty and void has no existence. If they are few, a scanty and meager faith is formed. If they are many, the faith is made rich and full in proportion to their abundance.
"But it must be borne in mind that the cognitions which make faith are the cognitions of genuine truth and good, and by no means the cognitions of falsity. For faith is truth; and falsity, because it is opposite to truth, destroys faith." (Doctrine of Faith 25-29).
And we read in the True Christian Religion: "Because charity and faith are distinctly two, yet make one in a man, that he may be a man of the church, that is, that the church may be in him, therefore it was a matter of controversy and dispute among the ancients as to which of the two must be first, and thus which by right is to be called the firstborn. Some of them said truth, consequently faith, and some said good, consequently charity. . . . But they overwhelmed their understanding with so many arguments in favor of faith that they did not see that faith is not faith unless joined with charity, and that charity is not charity unless joined with faith, and thus that they make one; and if not, neither of them is anything in the church. . . . Faith, by which is also meant truth, is first in time; but charity, by which is also meant good, is first in end. . . . Let this be illustrated with the building of a temple. The first thing in time is to lay the foundation, to raise the walls, to put on the roof, and afterwards to put in the altar and erect the pulpit; but the first thing in end is the worship of God therein, for the sake of which those things are done." (T. C. R. 336.)
In these two passages may be found the essential answer to the plea of those represented by the friends of David: "What shall the righteous do?" The eternal foundations of life and faith lie not in the ingenious doctrines of men, nor yet in the theories of men devised in these days as a substitute for doctrine, nor even in the interpretations of Heavenly Doctrine made by men or councils of men in the New Church. Such things may prove to be in error; and, in so far as they are false, they will crumble, without cause for distress or anxiety save to those whose faith is caught in their ruins. But the foundations of a genuine faith and a genuine life rest, as the text indicates, with the Lord, in His holy temple. For by the "holy temple" is signified the Divine Truth in the church. And the internal sense of this Psalm is, that with the man who enters into the Divine Truth by conjunction with a life of genuine charity, the Lord will fight against his evil in favor of the good; and that, in His Justice, the evil will perish.
9
Herein lies the power of the Church in a world of spiritual enemies,-a power so great that "they who are in the hands and arms and shoulders of the Gorand Man are they who are in power by means of the truth of faith from good; for they who are in the truth of faith from good are in the Lord's power, since they attribute all power to Him, and hone to themselves; and in the degree that they attribute none to themselves, not only with the mouth, but also with the heart, to that degree they are in power." (A. C. 4932.)
From this it may be seen that to those men and societies of men who so acknowledge the Divine Human in His Word, and obey His commandments, the Lord promises all power, and all defense and security, against their enemies. Naught shall make them dismayed. Naught shall destroy the foundations of their spiritual life. As it is written in the eternally beautiful words given through the mouth of the Psalmist:
"The Lord is my rock, and my fortress, and my deliverer; my God, my strength, in whom I will trust . . . The sorrows of death compassed me, and the floods of ungodly men made me afraid. The sorrows of hell compassed me about the snares of death prevented me. In my distress I called upon the Lord, and cried unto my God: He heard my voice out of His temple, and my cry came before Him, even into His ears.
"Then the earth shook and trembled; the foundations also of the hills moved and were shaken, because He was wroth. He made darkness His secret place; His pavilion round about Him were dark waters and thick clouds of the skies. Yea, He sent out His arrows, and scattered them; and He shot out lightnings, and discomfited them.
"He delivered me from my strong enemy, and from them which hated me: for they were too strong for me. Great deliverance giveth He to His king; and sheweth mercy to His anointed, to David, and to his seed for evermore." (Psalm 18.) Amen.
LESSONS: Psalm 2. Luke 6:39-49. T. C. R. 336.
MUSIC: Liturgy, pp. 509, 537.
PRAYERS: Liturgy, nos. 48, 187.
10